The Deconstruction Class was developed at the Mental Health Center in Longmont, Colorado in 2004. The context was a 10-week therapy play group for 7-10 year old boys. The idea for the group was to provide socialization and play skills. For many of this young boys the home environment was extremely chaotic and even sometimes dangerous. These were family situations with multiple problems including child sexual abuse, neglect, abandonment and poverty. I used a simple structure from my home preschool days. We began with an opening circle which consisted of greeting and check-in. Each child was asked to share something. I might ask a question. “What is the best thing that happened to you today?” Or “Tell me something fun that you did last night at home."
Then we would have snack. Each day there was a server, who handed out the plates, cups and napkins, then served each child. We had to wait until everyone was served, then we would all eat. After snack we would have project, or a game or activity. I had previously worked with children this age doing simple wood constructions mostly using small blocks of wood and glue, though occasionally I would introduce nails and hammering and simple sawing. I wanted to find a way to use more and different tools. I had the idea to take apart some simple small appliances. I tried it one day with a radio/tape player that didn't work anymore that I had at home. The boys took to it immediately. The excitement of opening up this appliance was fantastic. That moment when we took the back off was the best.
I visited a local thrift store on Main Street in Longmont and convinced them to give me their discarded (i.e.- no longer functioning and therefore unsellable) electronics and small appliances. These included, VCR’s, radio’s CD players, computer keyboards, an electric piano, a ceiling fan, blender. They were very grateful that I took the stuff they couldn't sell off their hands, and I was delighted to have am almost inexhaustible source for all kinds of interesting items to take apart.
The project was first to simply take apart the machines. The main rule was that you could not break anything. Everything had to be unscrewed and taken apart. I encouraged them to get things down to where there was nothing further to take apart. The individual components were then saved in a box.
Each day was an exciting adventure of discovery. The emphasis was on the boys doing this on their own. Of course, they would often need assistance, but they were encouraged to try to do as much themselves as they could. In fact, I would not help them unless they tried at least twice.
It was fascinating to see their personalities manifest in the face of this kind of challenge. They were enormously excited to be using real tools to take apart real things. These were not toys, but practical things they saw in their lives everyday in their homes, and in the homes of their friends and family. They had to work hard, especially in the beginning when they are mostly removing screws. Often they needed to have screws started, which I was glad to do and then they could remove them. They had to learn which way to unscrew. “Righty tighty, lefty loosey” was the phrase we used to remember this, but translating that phrase into a kinetic experience, into the actual repetitive turning was quite challenging for some of them. For others it was immediately pure joy. They were completely absorbed in this task. Some boys found the challenges almost overwhelming and would soon want to give up. They needed a little more encouragement and support. Some of them expressed their frustration loudly and easily. For them it was a challenge just to come back to the project, to calm themselves enough to continue.
It was a delicate balance between pushing them into compliance by the force of my ‘big’ self and allowing them to find their way into the process on their own. Sometimes they needed permission to not do anything. I would just let them be. Almost always they would be drawn back in by the other children, and by having the space to make their own decision and move at their own pace.
The best moment was when the screws were removed and the radio or tape player or VCR was opened and revealed its guts. This almost always created a huge “WOW”. The look of wonder, the excitement and satisfaction of accomplishment and success already, at this early stage, were inspiring and uplifting. Whatever else was going on in their lives, these moments were precious and fulfilling and healing all on their own. As a teacher and therapist, these moments made me feel like change was possible in these young lives. Entering the insides of these objects is like visiting a foreign country or an alien planet or, like looking into their own inner world and mind. And, of course, it didn’t stop there. They got to continue to take apart the insides of these machines.
We start with screws, but sometimes, even with all the screws removed, things would not come apart. What now? The excitement of new territory was not just theirs. I was learning right along with them. I discovered that there were many other ways that things were held together. Sometimes a clip needed to be pushed back to release a circuit board. Washers often held things together, or a nut had to be loosened from a screw. And fittingly, despite the ‘rule’ about not breaking, and apropos of much in their young lives, sometimes, after trying everything else first, the only way to proceed was to break something. This was also very satisfying. First, to get to break the rule, and second, to be able to break something when it was the only way forward. This was always something that had to be carefully considered and investigated and only when there is clearly no other option. Then we break.
Over the course of the 10 weeks, a child might take apart multiple pieces of equipment, or they might spend weeks on one thing. One child spent the entire time taking apart a video camera. They were all engaged and excited about what they were discovering. It wasn’t always easy . They had to share tools and wait their turn. Especially if they needed my help. They just simply had to wait. And they did. The level of industriousness and focus was very impressive. Many of these boys struggled in school and had trouble staying on task. Not here. It was fascinating to see them struggle with their habitual way of doing things, to see how they felt they should be treated. Some expected me to do things for them and were perplexed when I wouldn’t. Others just the opposite, not wanting me to do anything, not letting me or just not believing I would actually help them, so programmed to be neglected, not knowing how to receive my attention.
We continued taking things completely apart, down to the last screw or wire All along we are saving the interesting pieces, boxes and boxes of them while a lot of the bigger pieces, frames, cases, boxes, etc, we did not keep. The last class was the culmination. It was called Construction. All the small parts we were brought back out and each child could made a sculptural art piece using the various components of things they had taken apart. Sometimes a block of Styrofoam was used as a base, sometimes a cardboard box, sometimes just the pieces themselves.
This aspect presented a different kind of challenge. Now we were in the realm of free-form creativity. Some were hesitant and unsure while others plunged ahead fearlessly. This represented another step into the unknown. I believe their experience of things like legos made this easier in general or at least more familiar, then the deconstruction part It still represented a challenge.
The fact that they now had something to take home, something to show their parents and siblings gave them a genuine sense of pride and accomplishment. The parents were very impressed as well. For under achieving children to suddenly show up with a piece of art, a 3 dimensional sculpture, was very touching.
The benefits of Deconstruction are many and varied. It is a fun and engaging activity just on the surface. This makes it a learning experience to begin with because children learn through play. It engages children in a personal endeavor that involves cooperating and sharing tools. Because they are so engaged it increases attention span and the ability to focus. Staying with the process from beginning to end gives them an experience of delayed gratification when they succeed in constructing, making something completely new from the discarded pieces. I especially loved the application of these principles in the lives of these damaged children, the idea of taking apart the old that doesn’t work anymore and making something completely new out of what is available and our creative imagination. This is what they were doing with their young lives.
On another level, we are taking discards, used up items that are bound for the landfill, and recycling them in a delightful way. While many of the parts would eventually end up in the garbage, they were given another life, a different life in the service of wonder and learning, and at least what eventually finds its way into the landfill is in much smaller pieces. And most wonderful of all, some of the parts of these discarded object become art, and will be saved and cherished as such.
The program has changed since the days in Longmont. Now after one or two weeks of taking things apart, making sculptures is introduced and continues throughout the class. Partly this is in response to children who have taken Decon more than once and don’t want to wait to construct, and partly it is a response to the growing number of great parts that have accumulated in the ‘recycle boxes”.
At one point a parent who knew about machines and electronics pointed out that in many of these machines there are small motors, and that with two wires and a battery one could make those motors work. Most of the time this meant that s shaft would spin. This added a whole new level of possibility for sculpture, one that involved movement. The first child glued a piece of paper to the shaft of the motor and just made it go around and around. Then someone glued something harder to the shaft and positioned the motor so the extra piece hit against something and made a sound like a bell or noisemaker. Next we discovered rubber bands and belts and one young man almost made a car. Didn't quite get the tension right, but he was close.
Then there are switches. The most primitive one is a paper clip cut into two pieces, two pieces of wire and a battery and, of course, a small motor. It goes on from there, right up to pulling a switch mechanism out of a vacuum cleaner and re-wiring it to make your motor go on and off. Very cool.
From the very beginning I realized that I was not interested in doing a lot of things for the children that they could do themselves. There is an approach that seems to posit that the child needs to accomplish something fantastic and that it's ok if the adult does most of the work and the child takes the credit for it. It seems designed so that they can impress people and feel good about themselves. Adults around them know full well that the child did that with a huge amount of adult input, but not wanting to discourage the children, they go along. I wanted what they did to actually be there's. I actually believe that this is much more satisfying for them and, in the long run, of much more benefit to their self-esteem and relationship to the world. They are not fooled. They know when someone takes over a project and completes it for them, and they can become acclimated to such an approach, which is extremely debilitating to their own process.
I say very little about the creative part, the putting all these pieces of things back together in a totally different way. Nor did I offer to help them, though if anyone asked I am very willing to give a suggestion or assistance. Sometimes I would intervene with a suggestion if I knew where she was going and could provide a short cut. I say Yes to their internal, individual sense of what is needed now, in this moment. I will say “Some people like to find a base and then build up from there, but it's really up to you.”
Up to this point I have not really developed the ‘how does this work’ aspect beyond noticing what happens when you push this or pull that. I am getting to know what different parts of these machines are for, a capacitor, a circuit board, a condenser. I share this information freely, when appropriate. At the same time, they each have an individual encounter with a very specific manifestation of our technology and culture on a very visceral level, they are learning a lot. When they have done this class over and over, they have taken apart dozens of different kinds of contraptions.
In order to be as safe as possible, I observe certain rules:
1. I cut off the power cords before bringing the machines into class just so no one could plug something in “just to see what happens”.
2. I decided not to take apart anything with a screen: TV’s, Computer monitors, etc. because of the danger connected with taking apart glass things.
3. The children are carefully instructed that they are not to do this at home with their family appliances. (although sometimes parents are so enthusiastic that they actually provided opportunities for Deconstruction at home.)
Also there arose a need to make a rule about finishing what you start. It would be easy to take a large complex item, take it part way apart, then lose interest and want to do something else. So it became necessary to make an agreement and understanding at the beginning . Whatever you start taking apart, you are making a commitment to take it all the way apart. You must finish to the best of your ability. I am not afraid to help, especially if I see someone who has really put in a lot of time and effort and is just wearing down. But the standard is that you take everything completely apart. This is especially important when looking at a typewriter or a sewing machine, highly complex projects.
In terms of taking things home, the policy I developed is that anything that you change in some way is considered a sculpture and can be taken home. Other than that the pieces stay in your bag in the classroom. At the last class of the session you may take home 3 pieces that you have not built or sculpted as long as they are completely deconstructed. You can take any 3 things. This discourages the pack rats in the group from hording bags and bags of parts at home that parents then have to deal with at a later time.
I am curious to explore Deconstruction for adults and teenagers. So far I have had two adults, both women, one an artist, and the other just curious. They both seemed to enjoy it for different reasons, which is I suspect the secret of success in this realm. Everyone does it for their own special reasons and takes away their own private lessons. The form is big enough to accommodate all levels of exploration, even, maybe especially, the philosophical and spiritual, the sacred and the profane, the ordinary and the extraordinary that it contains.